Borderline personality disorder (BPD) can sometimes be misdiagnosed as bipolar disorder because the two conditions share symptoms such as mood instability, impulsivity, and irritability. When an evaluation focuses on these symptoms without reviewing the person’s history, important information can be missed. Seeing the full symptom patterns side by side makes the distinction clearer, our comparison of bipolar II vs. BPD symptoms covers each difference in detail.
Diagnostic confusion can also happen in the opposite direction. Someone with bipolar disorder may receive another diagnosis if earlier manic or hypomanic episodes were not recognized.
An inaccurate or incomplete diagnosis can affect treatment decisions. Understanding why mistakes happen, what a thorough reassessment involves, and when to seek a second opinion can help you take the next step.
Key Takeaways
- BPD can be mistaken for bipolar disorder, particularly when overlapping symptoms are evaluated without enough historical information.
- A mental health assessment should examine past mood episodes, changes in functioning, and persistent emotional or relationship difficulties.
- Screening questionnaires can identify possible symptoms but cannot establish a diagnosis without clinical evaluation.
- Medication effects, substance use, and other mental health conditions can complicate the diagnostic process.
- If your diagnosis does not seem to fit, you can request clarification or a second opinion without stopping your current treatment.
Can BPD Be Misdiagnosed as Bipolar Disorder?
Yes. Research has documented cases in which people with BPD previously received a bipolar disorder diagnosis that was not confirmed during a subsequent structured assessment.
A 2010 study published in the Journal of Psychiatric Research examined information from 610 psychiatric outpatients.
Researchers compared people who reported a previous bipolar diagnosis that was not confirmed through a structured interview with those who had never received that diagnosis and did not meet the interview criteria.
They found that BPD was associated with greater odds of reporting a previous bipolar diagnosis that the structured interview did not confirm.
However, the research involved a particular outpatient population, relied partly on participants’ reports of previous diagnoses, and used DSM-IV diagnostic interviews.
It does not establish a general misdiagnosis rate for everyone with BPD or bipolar disorder.
The findings do show why clinicians need to evaluate the complete symptom history rather than relying on overlapping features alone.
Why Does BPD Sometimes Get Mistaken for Bipolar Disorder?
Diagnostic confusion can arise for several reasons. The problem is not necessarily that one symptom was interpreted incorrectly. It may be that important information was unavailable or not fully explored.
1. The Term “Mood Swings” Does Not Explain the Full Pattern
People often describe changes in emotions using general terms such as mood swings, emotional instability, or feeling out of control.
These descriptions communicate distress, but they do not establish whether someone has experienced a clinically defined bipolar mood episode.
For example, irritability and impulsivity can occur in several mental health conditions.
A clinician needs additional information about when these experiences began, how they developed, and whether they represent changes from the person’s usual functioning.
Without that context, similar descriptions can lead to different diagnostic interpretations.
2. Earlier Manic or Hypomanic Episodes May Be Missed
Someone seeking help for depression may not remember or recognize earlier periods of hypomania.
A person might recall sleeping less, feeling unusually energetic, or becoming more active without considering those experiences part of a mental health condition.
This is particularly relevant to bipolar II disorder, where hypomania may not cause the severe disruption associated with full mania. Knowing what happens during a manic episode and how it differs from BPD-related emotional shifts, makes those earlier periods easier to recognize.
The National Institute of Mental Health notes that bipolar disorder can remain unrecognized when clinicians do not obtain enough information about earlier mood episodes.
When the history of mania or hypomania is incomplete, clinicians may consider other explanations for the person’s current symptoms.

3. Persistent Relationship and Self-Image Difficulties May Be Overlooked
An evaluation that focuses mainly on mood may not fully examine symptoms associated with BPD.
These may include recurring difficulties involving relationships, fear of abandonment, self-image, emotional regulation, or feelings of emptiness.
A clinician considers whether these symptoms occur across different situations and have been present over time.
These experiences cannot establish BPD by themselves, but they may indicate that further personality disorder assessment is appropriate.
4. Other Conditions Can Affect the Clinical Picture
Several other conditions can complicate an assessment for bipolar disorder or BPD.
Examples include ADHD, PTSD, depressive disorders, anxiety disorders, and substance use disorders.
Some physical health conditions and prescribed medications can also affect sleep, mood, energy, or behavior.
For instance, certain medications may contribute to agitation or unusually elevated mood. Substance use may produce symptoms that resemble or worsen psychiatric conditions.
A complete evaluation considers these factors before determining which diagnosis best explains the person’s experiences.
5. An Assessment May Not Capture Enough History
A single appointment cannot always establish the complete pattern of someone’s mental health symptoms.
People may have difficulty remembering when symptoms began, how long they lasted, or how their behavior changed.
Previous medical records, treatment history, and observations from trusted people may provide useful additional information.
With the person’s consent, a clinician may seek further details to better understand what occurred.
The goal is to make a diagnosis based on the strongest available clinical evidence rather than one account of a difficult period.
Can Bipolar Disorder Be Misdiagnosed as BPD?
Yes. Diagnostic confusion can occur in both directions.
Someone with bipolar disorder may initially receive another diagnosis if their history of mania or hypomania is incomplete or not recognized.
For example, a person may seek treatment during depression and describe emotional instability without mentioning an earlier period of unusually increased energy and activity.
A clinician may consider BPD or another condition before a more complete history becomes available.
However, this does not mean that every BPD diagnosis should be questioned or that every emotional change indicates bipolar disorder.
Both conditions have established diagnostic criteria.
A professional reassessment may confirm the original diagnosis, identify an additional condition, or lead to a different explanation. In some cases, an evaluation shows that a person genuinely meets the criteria for both bipolar disorder and BPD at the same time.
Can a BPD vs. Bipolar Test Identify a Misdiagnosis?
A screening questionnaire cannot independently determine whether a person has been misdiagnosed with bipolar disorder or BPD.
Screening tools are designed to identify symptoms that may require further evaluation.
Some questionnaires assess experiences such as increased energy, reduced sleep, impulsivity, or emotional difficulties.
However, these symptoms are not exclusive to one condition.
A positive screening result does not automatically confirm a diagnosis, and a negative result does not necessarily rule out a condition.
Questionnaires also depend on how people remember and interpret past experiences.
A clinician may use screening tools as part of an assessment, but they must consider the person’s history, symptoms, functioning, and other relevant information.
A 2026 review of research on distinguishing bipolar disorder from BPD found that diagnostic differentiation remains challenging and continues to depend heavily on clinical information.
Online quizzes should not be used to decide whether to stop medication, begin treatment, or reject an existing diagnosis.
What Does a Diagnostic Reassessment Involve?
A diagnostic reassessment is an opportunity to review an existing diagnosis in light of the person’s current symptoms and complete history.
It does not necessarily mean that the first diagnosis was incorrect.
Depending on the circumstances, a mental health professional may review several areas.
Previous Symptoms and Their Timeline
A clinician may ask when significant symptoms began, whether they occurred repeatedly, and how they affected everyday life.
The assessment may also consider periods when the person’s mood and functioning were different from their usual patterns.
Earlier Diagnoses and Treatment Records
Previous psychiatric evaluations, therapy records, and medication history may provide important information.
A clinician may examine which criteria supported an earlier diagnosis and whether additional evidence has emerged since then.
Medical History and Other Conditions
An assessment may include current medications, relevant medical conditions, alcohol or substance use, and other mental health symptoms.
Additional medical evaluation may be appropriate when physical health or medication effects could explain some symptoms.
Information From Other Sources
With consent, clinicians may consider information from family members, partners, or other trusted people who observed significant changes in behavior.
Such information can be helpful when the person does not clearly remember a past episode.
Review of Diagnostic Criteria
A qualified professional determines whether the available information supports the original diagnosis, another diagnosis, or more than one condition.
A structured diagnostic interview may be useful in some cases, but it is not a guarantee of a definitive answer.
The American Psychiatric Association’s BPD practice guideline emphasizes comprehensive assessment, review of co-occurring conditions, previous treatment, physical health, and the person’s goals.

What Signs Suggest Your Diagnosis May Need Another Look?
Having questions about a diagnosis does not mean it is wrong.
However, certain situations may make it reasonable to request clarification or reassessment.
You may want to speak with a qualified mental health professional if:
- Your diagnosis was made without discussing important parts of your symptom history.
- You have experienced significant changes in sleep, energy, or activity that were not previously evaluated.
- You received different diagnoses from different providers and do not understand why.
- New symptoms have appeared since your original assessment.
- Your current symptoms do not seem adequately explained by the existing diagnosis.
- You have received appropriate treatment but continue experiencing difficulties that have not been fully evaluated.
- You believe medication effects or another health condition may be influencing your symptoms.
None of these circumstances proves that a diagnosis is incorrect.
They indicate that a discussion with your clinician may be useful.
A diagnosis can remain appropriate even when symptoms change or treatment requires adjustments.
What Should You Do if You Think You Were Misdiagnosed?
If you suspect that your diagnosis does not fit your experiences, begin by discussing your concerns with a qualified mental health professional.
You do not have to identify the correct diagnosis yourself.
Ask Why the Diagnosis Was Made
Request an explanation of the symptoms and diagnostic criteria that supported the original assessment.
You can ask whether alternative explanations were considered and what information would be needed to review the diagnosis.
Prepare a Symptom History
Before your appointment, write down significant changes in mood, sleep, energy, behavior, and daily functioning.
Approximate dates and durations may be useful.
You do not need to document every emotion. Focus on changes that were unusual, prolonged, or particularly disruptive.
Bring Previous Treatment Information
If available, bring records of earlier diagnoses, prescribed medications, therapy, and significant treatment changes.
Include information about treatment benefits, side effects, and symptoms that continued despite care.
This can help a clinician understand what has already been tried.
Consider a Second Opinion
If you still have questions, you can request an assessment from another qualified mental health professional.
A second opinion provides an opportunity to review your history and consider whether the existing diagnosis is supported.
It does not automatically invalidate the original assessment.

Keep Your Current Treatment Team Informed
If you are taking prescribed psychiatric medication, continue following your treatment plan unless your prescribing clinician advises otherwise.
Stopping or changing medication without medical guidance can lead to complications or worsening symptoms.
What Questions Should You Ask During a Second Opinion?
Preparing questions can help you understand how a clinician is interpreting your symptoms.
Consider asking:
- Which diagnostic criteria support my current diagnosis? Ask what information the clinician considers most important.
- Was my history of mania or hypomania fully assessed? Discuss previous changes in mood, sleep, energy, and activity.
- Could another condition explain some of my symptoms? Ask whether medical, psychiatric, medication-related, or substance-related factors need further review.
- Would a structured interview or additional records help? Discuss whether more information could clarify the diagnosis.
- What would change if my diagnosis were revised? Ask how any change might affect treatment decisions.
- Should I continue my existing treatment during reassessment? Confirm medication and therapy recommendations with the appropriate clinician.
The purpose of these questions is to reach a clearer understanding of your symptoms, not to prove that a particular diagnosis is correct.
Can an Incorrect Diagnosis Affect Treatment?
Yes. An inaccurate or incomplete diagnosis can influence treatment decisions.
Bipolar disorder is commonly managed with medication and psychotherapy, while structured psychotherapy is generally the primary treatment for BPD.
If a person has not received a complete assessment, important treatment needs may remain unaddressed.
However, continued symptoms or limited improvement do not automatically mean someone was misdiagnosed.
Other factors, including medication response, treatment duration, side effects, co-occurring conditions, and symptom severity, can affect progress.
The American Psychiatric Association’s BPD guidance recommends structured psychotherapy for BPD and careful consideration of medication use.
If a diagnosis changes, the treatment plan should be reviewed with qualified professionals rather than altered independently.
What Happens After a Diagnostic Reassessment?
A reassessment can lead to several outcomes.
A clinician may confirm the original diagnosis and recommend continuing treatment.
They may identify another condition that helps explain symptoms not fully addressed by the current diagnosis.
In some cases, they may revise the diagnosis after reviewing additional evidence.
The clinician may also recommend further observation or evaluation if the available information does not support a clear conclusion.
Regardless of the outcome, the purpose is to develop a treatment plan that reflects the person’s current needs.
A revised diagnosis does not automatically mean previous treatment was harmful or unnecessary.
Similarly, confirmation of an existing diagnosis does not mean the person should continue an ineffective treatment plan without review.
When Should You Seek Urgent Mental Health Support?
A routine reassessment is not appropriate when immediate safety is a concern.
Seek urgent evaluation if you or someone else is experiencing severe behavioral changes, possible mania with psychotic symptoms, dangerous impulsivity, or an inability to remain safe.
Severe symptoms may require emergency psychiatric assessment or inpatient care rather than a standard outpatient appointment.
If you are experiencing suicidal thoughts or a mental health crisis in the United States, call or text 988.
Call 911 if there is immediate danger.
Where Can You Find Mental Health Assessment and Treatment Support?
Quest Wellness Center provides structured mental health treatment in North Hollywood, California.
Its medication management services include psychiatric assessment and ongoing medication oversight for conditions such as bipolar disorder.
Quest also offers personality disorder treatment for people experiencing BPD and related symptoms.
Treatment options include individual and group therapy, medication management, and structured outpatient programs.
Every group at Quest is led by a master’s-level therapist, supervised by licensed clinicians.
Services are available through Partial Hospitalization Programs (PHP), Intensive Outpatient Programs (IOP), and outpatient care, with in-person and telehealth options where appropriate.
If you have questions about an existing diagnosis, Quest’s team can explain its available services and whether its assessment and treatment options may be suitable for your needs.
Get Support When Your Diagnosis Does Not Fit
If your diagnosis does not seem to explain your symptoms, Quest Wellness Center can help you explore appropriate treatment options. Our team offers personality disorder treatment and medication management within structured outpatient programs when clinically suitable. Verify your insurance or call (818) 275-9810 to ask about available services and whether an assessment may be appropriate.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Often Is BPD Misdiagnosed as Bipolar Disorder?
There is no single reliable misdiagnosis rate that applies to everyone with BPD. A 2010 study of psychiatric outpatients found an association between BPD and reporting a previous bipolar diagnosis that was not confirmed through structured assessment. The results came from a specific clinical population and should not be interpreted as a general population rate.
Can Someone Be Diagnosed With Bipolar Disorder and BPD Together?
Yes. A person can meet the diagnostic criteria for both conditions. A clinician must assess each diagnosis independently rather than assuming that overlapping symptoms confirm both.
Does a Positive Bipolar Screening Test Confirm Bipolar Disorder?
No. A positive screening result suggests that further assessment may be appropriate. Screening questionnaires cannot independently establish bipolar disorder or rule out BPD. Diagnosis requires professional evaluation of the complete symptom history.
Can a Psychiatrist Reassess a Previous Bipolar Diagnosis?
Yes. A psychiatrist can review an existing diagnosis by examining current symptoms, past mood episodes, treatment history, medications, and other relevant factors. The assessment may confirm the diagnosis, identify another condition, or indicate that more information is needed.
How Long Does a Diagnostic Reassessment Take?
There is no fixed timeline. Some evaluations can be completed during an appointment, while others require additional interviews, medical records, or observation over time. The process depends on the complexity of symptoms and the information available.
Should I Stop Taking Bipolar Medication if I Think I Have BPD?
No. Do not stop or change prescribed psychiatric medication without medical guidance. Suspecting BPD does not prove that a bipolar diagnosis is incorrect, and some people have both conditions. Discuss your concerns with your prescribing clinician so your diagnosis and treatment can be reviewed safely.





